Gold, Guns and God, Vol. 9: Pushed Out Completely

A Biography of Swami Bhaktipada and a History of the West Virginia New Vrindaban Hare Krishna Community in Ten Volumes, by Henry Doktorski

Gold, Guns and God, Vol. 9 front cover

Gold, Guns and God, Vol. 9 front and back cover

SUMMARY: Volume 9—PUSHED OUT COMPLETELY

Volume 9 of Gold, Guns and God covers a nine-year time span roughly from 1987 to 1996. Chapter 93 tells the story of Bhaktipada’s 1991 trial in Martins Ferry, West Virginia. When he was convicted on Good Friday, the Brijabasis regarded it as the “darkest day in New Vrindaban history.” They took comfort in the coincidence that their spiritual master was convicted on the anniversary of the day Jesus Christ was crucified. They regarded this as a divine sign that Bhaktipada was innocent.

Chapter 94 details the events which occurred while Bhaktipada served time (about three months) in the Eastern Regional Jail in Martinsburg, and then about two years under house arrest in a rented apartment in Wheeling, while his appeals lawyer, the celebrated criminal attorney Alan M. Dershowitz, prepared his case in appellate court. Dershowitz claimed, “When I . . . read the transcripts, it was clear to me that this prosecution, even if the facts were identical, could not and would not have been brought against a mainstream religion, . . . the risk of religious bigotry having pervaded this case was just too great. So my interest in the case was primarily as a First Amendment lawyer, as a civil libertarian, as someone who cares deeply about the preservation of religious freedom.”

Chapter 95 describes the ten factors which permitted Bhaktipada’s Krishna-conscious Reformation to last for eight or so years, but it also describes the factors which ultimately led to its dissolution in 1994. Another important factor in the failure of Bhaktipada’s great experiment is outlined in Chapter 96: “The City of Fraud.” Bhaktipada defrauded the Indian Hindus who supported the community, the interfaith members who gave up their previous lives to move to New Vrindaban, and even the devotees who came to the community to follow in the orders given by Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada twenty-five years earlier. All were cheated by the alleged “pure devotee.”

Although Alan Dershowitz and his brother Nathan succeeded in overturning Bhaktipada’s Good Friday 1991 conviction, Bhaktipada, perhaps realizing that his influence at New Vrindaban was waning, resigned as “acharya” of the League of Devotees International. He appointed Radhanath Swami as his successor, but Radhanath refused to accept the position. None-the-less, in July 1993 when Bhaktipada returned triumphantly to the community he led for 25 years, most residents were joyful.

Finally, in September 1993, Bhaktipada tossed the last straw on the already heaping haystack of rumors of sexual abuse of boys and teenagers, by getting caught in the act during the Winnebago Incident. The eyewitness—Sarvabhauma dasa (Steven Travers)—was a respected member of the community and his testimony was believed by many. He noted, “The shit hit the fan,” and it did.

About half of the members of the community disregarded Sarvabhauma’s observation, but the other half believed him and lost their faith in Bhaktipada as a spiritual leader. In fact, many wanted him out. Tensions flared. Formerly friendly godbrothers became enemies because of their opinion of the Founder/Acharya of New Vrindaban. For some, it was like a civil war. Threats were uttered. One leader of Bhaktipada’s Far Eastern sankirtan pickers suggested that coffins should be procured for those who blasphemed the spiritual master.

After this, Bhaktipada spent most of his time traveling and preaching, or writing on his computer at his Silent Mountain retreat in his cabin in an abandoned limestone quarry about 25 miles south of New Vrindaban. Those who had rejected Bhaktipada as a spiritual authority eventually convinced him to peacefully resign as “acharya” and terminate the Great Experiment: the robes, English translations, the Western classical music, the female sannyasis, silent chanting, and the interfaith preaching. The pipe organ was sold, the six bronze bells were sold, as were the steel girders in the maha-dwaram gateway. The community was ruined. There wasn’t enough money to pay the electric bills (as Bhaktipada had appropriated all income for his legal defense) and the Palace went cold and dark. In fact, some called this the “Dark Age” of New Vrindaban.

It is said, “What goes up, comes down,” and nowhere was this seen as dramatically as at New Vrindaban.

TABLE OF CONTENTS—VOLUME 9: Pushed Out Completely

Chapter 93: A Good Day for a Crucifixion

    Dial Om For Murder
    Tirtha’s wife leaves him
    Tirtha becomes a swami
    Monkey On A Stick
    Bhaktipada indicted
    Who was behind the charges?
    Indian astrologer claims Bhaktipada “wrongly accused”
    Bhaktipada’s 53rd birthday
    Religious persecution
    Brijabasis blinded by great emotional investment
    Devotees believed allegations are “rumors and hearsay”
    Tirtha on trial for the murder of Steven Bryant
    Is there proof beyond a shadow of a doubt?
    A mistrial declared
    Bhaktipada on trial
    Bhaktipada purchases harpsichord during trial recess
    Bhaktipada convicted on Good Friday
    “They Finally Got the Swami”
    Bhaktipada preaches from jail
    North American GBC and temple presidents discuss the future of New Vrindaban
    Bhaktipada sentenced
    Bhaktipada forbidden to return to New Vrindaban after posting bail

Chapter 94: Under House Arrest

    Bhaktipada attempts to retire from management
    Bhaktipada displeased with disobedience and poor temple attendance
    Bhaktipada appoints Radhanath Swami as “Acharya” for the League of Devotees

Chapter 95: End of an Era

    Factors which made Bhaktipada’s great experiment possible
    Discontent
    “The Bengali-style kirtan rocked”
    The Westernized temple program: “sluggish and perfunctory”
    Nityodita Swami: a champion of the old ISKCON style
    Opponents of Christianization cite Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada
    Hodge-podge of all nonsense
    New-Age goulash
    Silent chanting not recommended
    Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada condemned Kirtanananda’s 1967 attempt to Westernize Krishna consciousness
    Bhaktipada: impersonalist
    Revolution
    Attendance and punctuality decline
    Dress at temple functions neglected
    Bengali kirtan never prohibited
    Bhaktipada sings gurvastakam prayers at Palace
    Other factors contribute to the dissolution of Bhaktipada’s changes at New Vrindaban
    Abuse of cows

Chapter 96: The City of Fraud

    Indian members disturbed by de-Indianization changes
    Feed cows to tigers in New Vrindaban zoo?
    “I don’t need Indian money to build my temple”
    Interfaith members defrauded
    The City of Fraud
    Bhaktipada’s controversial reforms
    Tangy grape juice
    Complete disbelief
    “I was disgusted”
    Brijabasis’ core beliefs challenged
    “Kirtanananda’s innovations are . . . extremely sinister and ominous”
    Christians disturbed by Bhaktipada’s “Christian-izations”
    New-Age Esotericism
    Bhaktipada “retires” and appoints Radhanath Swami “World Acharya”

Chapter 97: Bhaktipada’s Triumphant Return to New Vrindaban

    Conviction thrown out: The murder of Chakdradhari not conspiracy
    “Kidnapping” only a child custody case
    Testimony regarding homosexuality: “witchcraft trial of modern times”
    Convictions overturned
    Bhaktipada resigns as leader of New Vrindaban
    Bhaktipada returns triumphantly to New Vrindaban

Chapter 98: The Winnebago Incident

    The Parliament of the World’s Religions’ centennial celebration
    Bhaktipada caught having sexual activity with teenage male Malaysian disciple
    News of Bhaktipada’s sexual activity spreads throughout the community
    Bhaktipada: Avadhuta or sahajiya?
    Qualifications of guru
    Radhanath and Devamrita Swamis approach Bhaktipada
    Bhaktipada “confesses” for the first time
    Bhaktipada denies his “confession” for the first time
    Bhaktipada “confesses” for the second time
    Meeting in the cabin
    Bhaktipada denies his “confession” for the second time
    Confusion in India
    Buried gold unearthed at New Vrindaban
    Radhanath Swami departs
    Devamrita Swami departs
    Bhaktipada insists, “None of it [the rumors] is true!”
    Bhaktipada denies his “confession” for the third time: “I am completely innocent!”
    English noon and evening services terminated
    Indian disciples beg Bhaktipada to slay their doubts

Chapter 99: Admitting to “Past False Pride”

    The emperor’s new clothes
    I hear from the “horse’s mouth”
    I reveal my mind to my “spiritual master”
    New Vrindaban residents discover Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada’s 1967 letters chastising Kirtanananda
    Western classical music inappropriate at New Vrindaban
    Bhaktipada admits to “past false pride” and retreats to seclusion at Silent Mountain
    Faithful disciples rededicate themselves to Bhaktipada’s service
    “Everyone is acharya”
    My seventeen-page letter
    My letter criticized in Tirtha Swami’s Brijabasi Spirit
    Devotees disillusioned
    Reformers threatened

Chapter 100: “Civil War” at New Vrindaban

    Head injuries often affect sexual behavior
    Liturgical reforms caused by head injury?
    Bhaktipada’s innovations rejected
    Two separate morning services established: English and Sanskrit/Bengali
    Möller pipe organ sold
    The passing of Gudakesh
    Bhaktipada travels
    The mood of Vrindaban, India
    Chowpatty temple defects to ISKCON
    “What Prabhupada gave us is perfect”
    Two visions side by side?
    Petition promoted: a statement of resolution
    Radhanath Swami returns to New Vrindaban
    “Bhaktipada’s vision . . . must NOT be allowed to die!”

Chapter 101: Pushed Out Completely

    Two swamis visit Bhaktipada at Silent Mountain
    Nine points for Bhaktipada’s rectification
    The day the (English Western classical temple service) music died
    “I am the world acharya!”

Chapter 102: Picking Up the Pieces

    Temple assets sold
    Giant Prabhupada statue demolished
    Bhaktipada charged again in court; refuses plea bargain
    Tirtha Swami threatens to testify against Bhaktipada
    Bhaktipada’s 1996 retrial
    Tirtha’s devastating deposition crushes Bhaktipada’s defense
    Bhaktipada pleads guilty
    Murder conspirators not charged in court
    Bhaktipada left New Vrindaban in shambles
    Confusion reigns
    Devotees harassed because of New Vrindaban connections

Images

U. S. Geological Survey topographic map of McCreary Ridge showing location of principle sites of New Vrindaban.

Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada in the pavilion on the hill behind Bahulaban (September 1972).

Back to: Gold, Guns and God